| Year | Wrestler | Weight | Place |
| 2023 | Seamus Mack | 127 | 6th |
| 2022 | Seamus Mack | 126 | 8th |
| 2014 | Joey Goodhart | HWT | 7th |
| 2011 | Austin Miller | 112 lbs | 3rd |
| 2010 | Austin Miller | 103 lbs | 2nd |
| 2005 | Archie McConnell | 145 lbs | 4th |
| 2004 | Pat Hellmann | 189 lbs | 6th |
| 2004 | Corey Schwerin | 145 lbs | 4th |
| 2004 | Archie McConnell | 140 lbs | 3rd |
| 2003 | Matt Barnett | 140 lbs | 5th |
| 2003 | Corey Schwerin | 130 lbs | 8th |
| 2002 | Matt Barnett | 140 lbs | 6th |
| 2001 | Josh Schwerin | 130 lbs | 5th |
| 2000 | Troy Millhouse | 135 lbs | 2nd |
| 2000 | Matt Barnett | 125 lbs | 8th |
| 1999 | Rick Stauffer | 275 lbs | 7th |
| 1999 | Josh Schwerin | 103 lbs | 6th |
| 1997 | Dan Bechtold | 160 lbs | 5th |
| 1973 | John Malles | 95 lbs | 4th |