
| Wrestler | Career Wins |
| Austin Miller | 145 |
| Archie McConnell | 137 |
| Corey Schwerin | 135 |
| Seamus Mack | 131 |
| Reagan LeFevre | 125 |
| Matt Barnett | 124 |
| Josh Schwerin | 120 |
| Troy Millhouse | 115 |
| Woodie Hermann | 113 |
| Dakota Minnich | 110 |
| Dylan Bard | 109 |
| Joey Goodhart | 109 |
| Jordan Miller | 107 |
| Julian Colon | 106 |
| Ian Edwards | 105 |
| Caleb Mussmon | 103 |
| Jordan Ortiz | 97 |
| Giovanni Luciano | 96 |
| Aidyn Miller | 93 |
| Wrestler | Career Wins |
| Braden Edwards | 92 |
| Brandon Loperfido | 92 |
| Riley Mahosky | 92 |
| Dan Bechtold | 90 |
| Kyle Stevenson | 89 |
| Alan Stroman | 86 |
| Pat Hellmann | 85 |
| Mitch Weaver | 84 |
| Tommy Bennett | 84 |
| David Good | 84 |
| Rick Hake | 81 |
| Jim Schopf | 80 |
| Jerome Wiley | 78 |
| Tyler Reber | 76 |
| Dan Bennett | 75 |
| Russ Hanes | 72 |